The former site of Warren's Methodist Chapel and cemetery was sold in 1851 by Joseph and Matilda Warren Locke for $20 to the Methodist Episcopal Church, South, and at that time it became known as Pisgah. The earliest known burial was Sarah C. Bond in 1857. Rev. Reubert Burrow preached at Pisgah Church during the Civil War. An unknown Confederate soldier and many of the area's earliest families, including the Warren, Bond, Locke, Bartlett, McGowan, and Crenshaw families, are buried here. L.E. Detwiller became sexton in 1921 and served for 50 years. In 1972, Marion Hill Royer, a Bond descendant, succeeded him. In 1975, Pisgah Cemetery was incorporated and its name was changed to Bartlett-Ellendale Cemetery.