Early education in Ingleside began in the 1850s when settlers John P. and Susan Hatch Borden established Bay Seminary in 1854. Their school closed by 1860. Henry Nold bought land from the Bordens and opened Ingleside College in 1857, expanding the curriculum and building more frame structures for at least 30 boarding students. During the Civil War, the college buildings were torn down. A school in nearby Allendale was built about 1872 and remained active until 1910. The Ingleside public school system began about 1900.