Old Trinity Methodist Church, located at Broad and Lower Streets in Elizabethtown, is a historic Federal-style church built around 1848-1849, and it stands as a testament to quality craftsmanship that has endured for over 150 years. Added to the National Register of Historic Places in 1989, the church features original pine floors and curved pews that have witnessed the burdens of worshippers through tumultuous times. Significantly, it has a slave balcony, highlighting the complex history of segregation and resilience. The church cemetery hosts markers of notable figures like Argulus Poynter, a Revolutionary War veteran, and families whose histories are interwoven with the church's enduring legacy. Despite repairs necessitated by events like Hurricane Fran, Old Trinity Methodist Church is committed to preserving its rich history, continually focusing on maintenance efforts to uphold its spiritual and historical significance for future generations.