Methodists in the Bell and McLennan County region between Elm and Bull Hide Creeks erected a simple sanctuary in 1868 at the site of a nearby cedar log toll bridge. The Rev. James Peeler, a Waco district Methodist Circuit preacher, served the Cedar Bridge Church congregation in 1873. The community of Eddy, first known as Marvin when settled about 1880, shifted toward railroad tracks extended through the area by the Missouri, Kansas, and Texas Railroad in 1882. That year, a building known as Sage Chapel was moved from local rancher Charles Dunning's land to Eddy for use by Methodist and Baptist congregations. Eddy Methodist erected a new church building at this site in 1892. The present sanctuary, built in 1912 through the efforts of the Rev. S.B. Knowles, is a good example of an Akron Plan church, with elaborate German-made stained glass windows, a stamped metal ceiling, and Prairie School influences including overhanging eaves with brackets, a hipped roof, and tower. Bruceville and Eddy Methodist Churches merged to form the Bruceville-Eddy United Methodist Church in 1983, and renovation of the sanctuary in 1993 included placement of the Bruceville church bell in the belfry.