Goshen Church was built about 1751. It was served by the early pastors of the Salzburgers, and later for a short time by Moravian missionaries. The church remained part of the Ebenezer Charge until after the Revolutionary War. In 1820, the Methodist Church was organized at Goshen under the direction of the Rev. James O. Andrew and was allowed to use the Goshen church edifice, with the deed to the property transferred to the Methodist Conference several years later. Among the first members of the Goshen Methodist Church were David Gougle and his daughters, Mrs. Nowlan, wife of Major Nowlan, and Major and Mrs. John Charlton. The Rev. Lewis Myers moved to Goshen about 1823 and served the Methodist Church there for many years.