Zoar Separatists built the hotel in 1833 to accommodate overflow travelers from their original Ohio & Erie Canal inn. It became an economic boon to the Zoar community but, by bringing the outside world into Zoar, ultimately became a source of discontent for members. During its heyday, the hotel catered to curiosity-seekers, visiting artists, and families escaping the summer heat of nearby cities. Notable guests included Marcus Hanna and President William McKinley. The original structure was enlarged several times, including the now demolished Queen Anne addition that doubled the accommodations. By the mid-twentieth century, the hotel remained open as a popular restaurant with a Rathskeller bar until closing to the public in July 1983. The exterior was restored by the Ohio History Connection in 2001-2002.