Founded on or before July 27, 1828 by Isaac Boring, a Methodist circuit riding preacher, this frontier Methodist society was first known as The Black Creek Methodist Church and met in homes until the present church was built in 1847. In continuous use since that date, the structure represents the oldest Methodist meeting place in Florida. It was built mostly by slave labor from native lumber and hand wrought nails made by local blacksmiths, with a heart of pine exterior of clapboard square edge siding, a design unique to this period. The windows and the mahogany wood for the pews were brought from overseas ports. The bell was cast in New York in 1852 and shipped here prior to 1860 by George Branning, and it was tolled for the first time for the funeral of his son on February 29, 1860, after he died during a swamp fever epidemic. A wide aisle was left down the center to segregate men and women, and the back pews were reserved for slaves. The pews were put together with wooden pegs and hand drawn, and the marks of the draw-knife can still be seen. During the mid 1800s the cemetery was used to bury the town Protestants, while the Catholic Cemetery was located 120 feet north of here. In recent years the cemetery became the burial ground for the community in general.