Methodism came to this area in the late 18th century as pioneering circuit riders such as Francis Asbury visited local residents to spread their faith. The origin of this congregation dates to 1859, when members of two local Methodist societies joined together to establish a new church at this location. Their former meeting places, known as Onin’s or “Gully Camp” and “Russell Church,” were abandoned after the move. Construction of the present house of worship began in July 1859, and it was named Chaplain’s Chapel Methodist Episcopal Church in recognition of the efforts of Reverend John Chaplain, the church’s first minister. A graveyard was later established for the use of members.