Organized in 1857 and originally known as Mount Carmel, this church was the first Presbyterian congregation established in Shelby County. A one-room log cabin served as its meeting place until a large two-story frame building was constructed in 1877. That building was used by the Presbyterian, Methodist, and Baptist churches in the Tennessee community, and it also served as the public schoolhouse and as the lodge hall for the Woodmen of the World. Tennessee Presbyterian Church built its own sanctuary at this site in 1914, and it served the congregation until a new structure was built and dedicated in 1957. The earliest church roll dates from 1858 and lists E.T. Corley, Charley H. Corley, Mary Pitman, Mary Watts, R.R. Johnson, Martha Ann Johnson, and John F. Ramsey as members. Some of the early settlers of the community attended church here. The congregation was first served by circuit riders, but in 1866 the Rev. Mitchell Smith became its first full-time pastor. Over the years, Tennessee Presbyterian Church has continued to uphold the ideals and traditions of its founders, and as one of the oldest organizations in Shelby County, it is an important part of the area's heritage.