Methodism in this part of Delaware traces to the early 1770's, when a Methodist Society was organized and began meeting in the home of Isaac Hersey, a prominent farmer and miller. Through the efforts of Hersey's step-son William McIntire and others, the land on which Salem Meeting House was constructed was obtained in 1807, and the congregation was formally incorporated on October 16, 1807. Bishop Francis Asbury preached there on several occasions. The church was remodeled several times during the 19th century, was completely renovated in 1904, gained a Fellowship Hall in 1958, and added the current sanctuary next to the hall in 1987. Members of the congregation were also instrumental in establishing Tyson's Chapel in Newark and Christiana Methodist Episcopal Church in the early 19th century, and Salem United Methodist Church continues to serve the spiritual needs of its community.