After several years of fundraising by Historic Hayesville, Inc. and support from individual donors, the old Hayesville Town Hall was moved in 2019 for preservation as part of Clay County history and taken to Hayesville Heritage Park, where partner non-profits the Clay County Communities Revitalization Association and the Clay County Historical & Arts Council feature historic sites. Located below the CCCRA Cherokee Homestead and CCHAC Old Jail Museum and within walking access from downtown and the Clay County Schools campus, the 1930s building represents early twentieth-century architecture around Hayesville Town Square, where wooden buildings were later replaced by brick in the 1940s. Originally a 15-foot by 25-foot structure near the Historic Courthouse Square, it was modified and used from the 1930s to the 1950s as City Hall, the Tax Office, and storage for the town's early fire hose before passing into private ownership under local resident Frederick Russell "Red" Benedict. It later held various collectors' items and declined into a storage shed until Benedict's daughter, Betty Lyon, offered it as a donation, leading Historic Hayesville, Inc. to accept it with plans to preserve it as a classroom for historical, cultural, and art classes or outdoor festival presentations. Its interior and exterior include repurposed elements from other historic or period buildings, including the 1930s Hayesville Post Office, the Historic Courthouse, and the former elementary school, along with original wood structure features, an added front porch, and a school bell. After private owners moved it from the square to more than one location beginning in the 1950s, rehabilitation was completed in the spring of 2023 by Woodhaven Construction with help from Historic Hayesville, Inc. volunteers and community donations. The building, saved through a budget of at least $35,000, reflects the combined efforts of the Clay County Historical & Arts Council, the Clay County Communities Revitalization Association, and Historic Hayesville, Inc. for downtown revitalization, historic preservation, and activities for all ages.