Kinsey Baptist Church was organized in 1891 as Enon Baptist Church and was also formerly known as First Baptist Church of Kinsey and Kinsey Baptist Church of Christ, with the present name adopted in 1907. Organizational services were overseen by Rev. Ephraim Knowles. Fourteen charter members drew up and signed a church covenant and were led in singing "Amazing Grace" before extending to each other the hand of fellowship. Rev. D.E. Burdeshaw served as the first pastor. Early meetings were held on the second Saturday and Sunday of each month. In 1911, the church reported 68 active members. In 1956, a brick building replaced the first wooden structure, and the original church bell is displayed on the property. A new sanctuary was constructed in 1978.