Beards Creek Church was orderly constituted on December 29, 1804, by the Rev. John Gooldwire, the Rev. John Standford, the Rev. Isham Peacock, and the Rev. David Hennesy, all orderly Baptist ministers. Jacob Dees and Moses Westberry were ordained deacons that day, David Hennesy was called as the first minister, and Nathan Smart was clerk. Its organizing members were John Dees, John Taylor, William Willcox, Samuel Thornton, Levi Morgan, Robert Bruer, James Thomas, Ezeceal Thornton, John Overstreet, Seth Knight, Nathan Smart, and John Purcell. The church was constituted near the site of the present edifice. On November 26, 1896, Beards Creek Church, with seven others, became an organizing member of the Bethel Primitive Baptist Association. In the years since its constitution, many Baptist churches in the surrounding area originated from Beards Creek Church.