On this site stood the Second Presbyterian Church of Cranbury, built in 1838 on Church Street, now Westminster Place. In 1837, a number of members of the First Presbyterian Church withdrew and established a new house of worship on this property. The Second Presbyterian Church served its congregation for almost a century until the reunification of the First and Second Presbyterian congregations in 1935, accomplished largely through the efforts of Rev. Frank B. Everitt, pastor of the Second Presbyterian Church from 1929 to 1935. The church building was torn down in 1936. Adjacent to the site, the Sexton's House at 3 Westminster Place was built in 1840 as the sexton's home and was later modified. The church chapel, later known as the Westminster House, once stood near the current driveway of the Sexton's House, became the Cranbury Youth Center in 1945, and served numerous community functions for several decades after the church was razed. Across the street stood horse sheds for those attending services, and the current garage for the Sexton's House was rebuilt in the 1970's from the last of those sheds. Westminster Cemetery was first established for the congregation and relations of the Second Presbyterian Church, later opened to members and relations of the First Presbyterian Church after the merger, and is now open to all regardless of religious affiliation. A monument built in 1940 on the church's original site preserves the memory of the Second Presbyterian Church and honors the ten pastors who served it.