Founded in early 1886 on a wooded site, Oak Grove Methodist Church was organized with 30 members and was one of five churches on the Keller circuit. A building acquired from another church was moved onto the property in 1887. Members built a brush arbor for summer meetings and revivals attended by community members of all faiths. Some Oak Grove members formed Colleyville Methodist Church in 1924, though most Colleyville members continued to attend Oak Grove services for many years. In 1925 the early house of worship was replaced. Oak Grove had 99 members in 1935, but as population centers changed, its membership declined. By 1949 the church had only twelve members and was dissolved early that year. Its last building was moved to Colleyville and used by that congregation from 1950 to 1961.