Pultneyville's lake captains included Commander of Schooner Samuel Throop, Farmer in 1810; Russell Whipple, Enterprise in 1811; Charles Snow, Lark in 1812; Russell Cole, Caroline in 1814; Judson Pond, Hiram in 1823; Henry Wood, Atlas in 1824; Horatio N. Throop, Sophia in 1825; Horace Morley, Commerce in 1827; Washington Throop, Enterprise in 1833; John Stevenson, Three Brothers in 1833; Edward Todd, Wayne in 1849; Andrew Holling, Free Trader in 1849; John Todd, Wayne in 1850; John Palmer, Albion in 1850; B.B. Brewer, Challenge in 1855; Armine Holling, Rival in 1856; Samuel D. Tomkinson, Thomas Kingsford in 1859; James T. Holling, Rival in 1862; John H. Ledyard, S.S. Cataract in 1862; Milton Fairbanks in 1824; J.G. Roys, Union in 1869; John Burtiss, Union in 1869; John Sheffield, H.M. Ballou in 1869; William Leaver, Grace Sherwood in 1869; Russell Smith, S.S. City of Concord in 1869; M.V. Pallister, Fred L. Wells in 1881; and John Todd, J.J. Hill in 1869.