This first permanent home for the parish was formerly located on Washington Street and was dedicated on March 9, 1919, although Mass had been celebrated since 1913 in temporary locations by priests from Saint Leo Abbey. Father Felix Ullrich, OSB, was its first priest and served here until 1932. Originally built facing south, the church was heavily damaged by a hurricane in 1921, which lifted the building, left it facing west, and removed the belfry. Father Felix, who was praying at the time, escaped unharmed and, after surveying the structure, said, "Well, if that's the way God wants it, we'll just have to leave it that way." The parish moved into a new building on Allamanda Drive in 1966. This building was moved here in 2001 by the city of New Port Richey, and restoration was completed in 2005.