Neals Creek Baptist Church was formally organized in 1803 after previously being an arm of Big Creek Baptist Church near Williamston. It was served by Rev. Moses Holland of Big Creek Church until Revs. Robert King and William McGee became joint pastors in 1829. Members originally met in a log building northeast of here. The church was a founding member of the Saluda Baptist Association in 1803. In 1832, Edward Vandiver, a charter member and Revolutionary War veteran, donated this site to the church. In 1871, congregants replaced an older frame church with one built of locally produced brick. The brick church was remodeled and expanded in 1939 and served the church until a new sanctuary was completed in 1985. An education building was added in 1963.