Four previous church buildings have stood on this approximate site. The first meeting house was constructed in 1733 when the congregation first gathered. A new building was necessary in 1775 to accommodate the congregation's growth. The third building, constructed in 1840, was destroyed by fire on Sunday February 7, 1875. The fourth building, constructed in 1875, was destroyed by fire on Sunday December 13, 1964. The present building was dedicated on June 18, 1967.