Henderson County Methodists were first organized in 1852 by the Rev. Hezekiah Mitcham, and worshipers met in homes and brush arbors around the county. In 1854, the Rev. W.M. Sansom was assigned to this circuit, and in 1859 he formally organized 12 churches, of which the church at Athens, with 45 members, was the largest. Mrs. Dulcinea (Thompson) Avriett (1835-1920) was the last surviving founder with continuous membership. In 1884, after meeting in the sanctuaries of the Athens Baptist and Presbyterian Churches, the congregation acquired a lot on West Tyler Street and constructed a frame church building. In 1904, after property on the southeast corner of the public square was purchased by the Ladies Aid Society, a new stone and brick sanctuary was completed. An educational building was completed in 1931 and was later dedicated to Henderson County pioneers Judge and Mrs. J.J. Faulk. The sanctuary on the square served the congregation for sixty years, and with its emphasis on Christian education and community service, the United Methodist Church of Athens has continued to uphold the ideals and traditions of its founders. The congregation has worshiped at this site since 1964.