The Perrysville Methodist Episcopal Church was organized in 1833 with Rev. E.C. Merriman as its first minister. On December 8, 1968, it merged with the Perrysville Evangelical United Brethren Church to form the present Perrysville United Methodist Church. It was offered to the Carroll County Historical Society as a historic landmark and was accepted as such on January 19, 1972. It was dedicated on June 30, 1974.