New York Cemetery, established in the 1870s near the local Methodist Church, grew from a tiny burial ground through generous land donations by area settlers. The earliest marked grave is that of Enoch Tunnell, who lived from 1816 to 1879. Twelve more graves appeared by the end of 1883, including those of many infants and young children. Martha Dismuke gave an acre of land to the Methodist Church for a public graveyard in 1883. She was the mother of Rissa Dismuke Hall, the third wife of Dr. Thomas Hunt Hall, a physician and circuit-riding Methodist minister. Their nine children were cared for by Martha Dismuke after Rissa Hall died in 1891. The Rev. James Carr Walker, who established the first New York Community Store and the Methodist Church, sold parcels of his extensive landholdings to newly settled farmers. He and his wife, Mary Fain Walker, had ten children. Mary Walker gave half an acre for the public cemetery in 1884 following James Walker's death. Nancy E. Walker, a daughter of James and Mary Walker, and her husband John Harrison Reynolds are reported to have given an additional half acre of land to the cemetery. Horace Clinton Hall, a son of Dr. Thomas and Rissa Hall who owned the New York Store for several years, and his wife Viola Beckham Hall gave more land to the growing cemetery. Dennis W. Sholars and Clara Tindel Sholars and Seaborn Calvin Tindel and Laura Garrett Tindel gave the southern portion of the cemetery in 1939. One of the first graves in that section was that of Clara and Calvin's father, Seaborn F. Tindel, in 1941. By the end of the 20th century, the cemetery included more than 600 graves and continued to serve as a chronicle of the New York community.