In 1876, Corydon E. Cooley and Marion Clark, two ranchers who had both laid claim to and eventually became partners in managing 100,000 acres of land at the northwest edge of the White Mountains, decided the land could not support two families. Neither man was willing to buy the other out, so they settled the matter with a friendly game of Seven Up at the kitchen table of Cooley's two-story home atop the hill directly south of where a church now stands. As the game neared completion, Cooley needed just one point to win. With nothing else to lose, Clark, holding a three, exclaimed, "show low and you win the ranch." Cooley drew the Deuce of Clubs, renamed the ranch Show Low, and the main street became known as the Deuce of Clubs.